The Best of the Oughts
2000 - CarcassonneThis game needs no introduction. If you haven't played it, shame on you. That said, this year was a toss-up for me...
Runner Up: Cartagena. Shame on you if you havent' played this game as well. Cartagena is probably the best filler game ever (i.e. a game you play to fill time between other more substantial games). It's status as a filler game is why it lost to Carcassonne, but I probably have—and probably will—play more games of Cartagena in my lifetime.
Honorable Mention: Taj Mahal, a fine Reiner Knizia bidding game.
2001 - (Traders of) GenoaAs Randy Buehler has already pointed out, this was a weak year. However, Traders of Genoa (aka Genoa) is an all-time favorite.
Honorable Mention: Dragon's Gold, the Euro gamer's answer to Munchkin.
Also Check Out: Don, an oft-overlooked Mafia-themed bidding game.
2002 - Lord of the Rings: The ConfrontationThis was as strong year, that saw the release of many good candidates for Game of the Decade. Lord of the Rings: The Confrontation is my likely pick for that title. Far and away the best game on the LotR franchise, and quite possibly Reiner Knizia's best work ever.
Honorable Mention: Age of Steam. I only started playing this recently, and apparantly it has had a couple of revisions since then (Railroad Tycoon and now Steam), but I am very impressed.
Honorable Mention: Star Wars: Epic Duels. Way better than you would expect a Star Wars-branded, Hasbro-developed game to be.
Also Ran: Puerto Rico. This one obviously tops many peoples Game of the Decade lists. I also was enamored with it when it came out, but the gild left the rose very quickly for me. I find its pacing to be awkward, and its strategic landscape to be a minefield of suckerpunches. This is my pick for Most Overrated Game of the Decade.
Also Check Out: Clans; Trias; Too Many Cooks
2003 - Vanished PlanetI admit that my pick for this year is a little unusual. This game is an indie (read: amateur) effort, and it shows. The rulebook is illustrated with high-school-quality pencil sketches, the kind you see most often on D&D character sheets. Of the rulebook's eighteen pages, ten are devoted to narrative prose. It's one table was obviously printed on a matrix printer. All that said, I find Vanished Planet to be a charming piece of Naive Art. It's a cooperative game, where each players represent different alien races, all working together to thwart the giant galaxy-eating space amoeba. In most of my games the pacing has been spot-on, with the threat of disaster looming ever larger, and victory coming at just the nick of time. The games we played mostly managed to avoid the one-overlord-player-who-bosses-everyone-a
Honorable Mentions: Alhambra; Attika; Fearsome Floors; Fish Eat Fish; King Me. This was a solid year with many good games but few really bright stars.
2004 - San JuanFixed the bugs in Puerto Rico, and inspired Race for the Galaxy. Well done!
Honorable Mention: Ticket to Ride. I'm prejudiced against rail games, and against Alan Moon, so this game almost snuck by me. It's a good game, though!
Honorable Mention: Sunken City, a clever race game on shifting terrain.
Honorable Mention: Duell. This might actually take the top spot if I had played it more than once. But since that one time I have been searching for a copy.
Also Ran: Power Grid I do not enjoy the victory-sprint-detente dynamic of this game. Overrated.
Also Check Out: Tongiaki
2005 - CaylusAnother contender for Game of the Decade. This game epitomizes the action-drafting genre, adding a spatial component—albeit a linear one—that other games before and since are so obviously missing.
Honorable Mention: Vegas Showdown, the game that Amun-Re should have been. I find the pacing to be slightly languid; while most Euro games leave me shouting "hey, I was playing that game!" Vegas Showdown has me mumbling "get on with it already."
Honorable Mention: Descent: Journeys in the Dark. Thanks to this game, I may never play D&D again.
2006 - Great Wall of ChinaThis is a pristine little gem of a game. It achieves what most games can only strive for: to fit perfectly and snugly inside its design space, creating a sense that this is the only version of this game that could exist, with no room for expansion.
Honorable Mention: Through the Ages. Vlaada Chivatl is the new rising star of board game design. If you've been looking for a good board game version of Sid Meier's Civilization, look no further.
Honorable Mention: Arkadia. Similar to Acquire in its mix of spatial deployment and market speculation. I wish the fiction were a better fit.
Honorable Mention: Taluva. Like Carcassonne, but shorter, more tactical and with more direct confrontation. Can be played as an appetizer or a main course.
Special Innovation Award: Space Dealer, a valiant attempt at a real-time board game.
2007 - Galaxy TruckerYes. I said it. Galaxy Trucker. Not Agricola, and not Race for the Galaxy either. This game wins on originality. I'm sorry that you don't like it because you made some noob mistake and got your ship blowed up. Space trucking is a job for men, not fuzzy bunnies.
Runner Up: Race for the Galaxy. Don't get me wrong. I love Race for the Galaxy, but it borrows too much from San Juan to get my pick for this year.
Runner Up: Agricola. I love Agricola too, but honestly I find it to be a little too much of a chore to play. The return on investment just isn't as good.
Also check out: Notre Dame
2008 - DominionIf you have not played this game, please stop reading now, go to a game store and buy it. (Not you, Mom, just everyone else.) This isn't so much a contender for Game of the Decade as it is the first game of the next decade. I predict that Dominion's mark will be found on many games of the "tens."
Honorable Mention: Witch's Brew. I am in awe of this game. A trick-taking game with the actual trick-taking part amputated and replaced with action drafting. Or something. I wish I could in good conscience pick it over Dominion.
Honorable Mention: Pandemic, a very good cooperative game. I love the way this game uses its card deck; the discards get put back on top of the deck causing history to repeat itself.
Honorable Mention: Le Havre. I might like this game more than Agricola. The narrative dimensions of this game are very compelling, making it easy to enjoy even when you're losing.
Also check out: Zooloretto